On Your Side: Judge downplays abuse in custody case

Reported by: Joe Hart
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Updated: 1/27/2014 7:02 pm
RENO, Nev. (MyNews4.com & KRNV) -- Antonio Morales showed us a binder full of pictures he says were taken by Clark County Child Protectives Services showing his daughter Abbigail and the injuries she suffered, allegedly, at the hands of her mother in 2011.

"Injuries on top of injuries. Bruises that were already healing, with fresh bruises on top of that," Morales said.

Abbigail's mother, Roxana Arteaga, was arrested in June of 2013 by Metro Police in Las Vegas on a felony charge of child abuse, and is currently awaiting trial. But that hasn't stopped her from filing for custody of her children, Abbigail and Robert, who currently live with their father in Reno.

It also hasn't stopped Clark County Family Court Judge Jennifer Elliot from considering Roxana's request. A trial is set for Wednesday to decide who gets primary physical custody of the children, even though the mother is currently out on bail, awaiting trial on that child abuse charge.

When Judge Elliot's office was questioned, her staff said the judge's policy is to wait for resolution of the criminal matter before proceeding on custody issues.

Antonio says he's simply asking for the judge to follow her own policy in this case. "I would love for her to acknowledge that there is a criminal case and for her to step back and say let's see what happens and then go from there. It's only fair," Morales said.

But Judge Elliot is pushing forward expressing concern that Antonio is "alienating" the children from their mother. She cites that as the biggest issue in this case, not the allegations of child abuse.

"I think the alienation might have outgrown any other issue," Judge Elliot said, on the record, during a recent court hearing.

That means Antonio's children could end up in the custody of a parent who is formally charged with abuse and neglect.

Antonio says all he can do is hope that's not the outcome. "It is really hard to swallow that they could leave me and go the abuser," he said.
28 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

annonymous - 11/22/2014 4:47 PM
0 Votes
If you read the latest "minutes" of the mothers criminal case, it looks like this psycho judge gave the children to the mother even thought the criminal case is still ongoing and a trial set for December. Those poor kids. :(

annonymous - 11/22/2014 4:31 PM
0 Votes
It does not matter if the abuser is the mother or the father, this judge has given custody to abusers of both genders just to keep the money flowing through the court system. If she truly did what was in the best interest of the children then family court wouldn't be paid as much. She hurts the children and the good parent that will spend every last dime and then some to fight for whats right for their babies.

annonymous - 11/22/2014 4:23 PM
0 Votes
She is a horrible judge. She does not care about children and uses the "alienation" excuse as a way to help her evaluator/psychiatrist friends earn more money off of good parents that will do anything to keep their children in their lives. Many times she will give custody to the abuser by saying the other parent is alienating the children. Karma needs to catch up with her soon for all the harm she has caused to many innocent children and families.

justice dads - 8/9/2014 9:20 AM
0 Votes
I have been in a 5 year battel with my xwife in the reno court regarding custody and parental time with my kids. The judge i have is PECK. PECK has been extremely one sided in her rulings toward me the father. Has anyone else had issues with PECK? I am trying to get a case against her and get the news media involved to show her blatant discrimination. The family system is broken badly

fathersrights - 5/29/2014 2:51 PM
0 Votes
Oh... Adding to my previous comment... we have also reported the neglect/abuse to CPS... but they will not do anything!!

fathersrights - 5/29/2014 2:40 PM
0 Votes
My Boyfriend is going through almost the same thing... His Ex wife has been abusive and we have proof of the harm both mentally and physically done to this 5 year old child... and yet the Judges in this area still gives the child to the mother with primary custody! What help can we get???

vegas val - 5/5/2014 6:29 PM
0 Votes
omg I just got assigned to her , this is my worst fear, it took me a long time to get enough evidence & courage to take on my ex husband & his lawyer-I have no lawyer & I just had a case filed against him and it landed with this judge . I wanted to see who she was & all I see on every web site is bad. Why dont judges listen to the kids!! I saw an 11 yr old girl this morning crying , terrified at the court house , i think she was being sent to visit her dad who is an abuser, WTF happend to protecting the children. I am so afraid of my upcoming court date , & that she wont read evidence.

bigmama - 1/31/2014 10:21 AM
2 Votes
This judge is sending out a horrible message! With all the violence going on in the world right now, this woman is going to let parents everywhere think its ok to abuse your kids and get away with it. Not to mention the lesson being taught to these children! They will now think there's no one to turn to the next time they're abused. Who do they call? The same people that are going to force them back with the abuser?! This system is failing our children and it needs to end. This judge needs to step down if she's not going to do what's obviously best and let someone take her place that can break the chain of abuse!

CourtneyRenee - 1/30/2014 3:33 PM
1 Vote
I can't even begin to comprehend why this has gotten this far. Is there really a question about who should hold custody of these children? This man is clearly doing everything he possibly can to save his children from this mentally impaired woman! Were the pictures not enough alone? Does she (the judge) need a better prescription for her glasses? The fact that the mother is on bail and awaiting trial for CHILD ABUSE/ENDANGERMENT should put an end to the whole situation. If she was arrested that means there was evident proof of abuse... Um, HELLO?!?!? I just don't understand. Give this man his children, PLEASE!

Konagirl - 1/29/2014 2:11 AM
1 Vote
Okay so this is telling me that I can beat the hell out of my kids and do nothing for them, yet I will still have more rights than the parent that has done everything to save them. Judge do you know or understand the rulings you make? This makes me so sick. I wonder would the judge do this if the dad was the abuser? Would she favor him this much? I think not it would just be another static for her books. Judge where do you feel any of this is fair? Think about this would you want your son with YOUR grandkids to experince this? Oh thats right because your a judge you'll get the best that money can buy and you won't have sleepless nights like these kids and father have been having. Good job judge way to show these kids the justice system does nothing for them.

Featured Segments/Shows

All content © Copyright 2015 Intermountain West Communications, LLC. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
You may also view our Sitemap

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.