Welcome to the all new MyNews4.com

Wild horse advocates bid high to save horses

Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 9/20/2012 10:55 pm
MOUND HOUSE, Nev. (Mynews4.com & KRNV) - Members of a local wild horse advocacy group say they were forced into paying more than necessary during a bidding war  at a livestock sale in Fallon, Nevada. Now, they want auctions to halt.  President of Hidden Valley Wild Horse Protection Fund, Shannon Windle spearheaded fundraising efforts to buy 23 horses.  "We received donations locally, nationally and internationally.  They are people who are concerned and want to see that these horses don't end up in slaughter houses," said Windle.

Windle says they spent more than $11,000 on the horses. "That’s way over what we had anticipated even budgeted for," she said.  Windle says they were there to outbid kill-buyers, but ended up going up against the owner of the livestock yard in a bidding war. "He was obviously running up the price of horses," said Windle.

It has not been confirmed that the owner was in fact bidding against the horse advocates. However, Jim Barbee, Director of the Department of Agriculture says it is legal for the owner to bid on livestock.  Barbee also compared the price of the horses to the stock exchange. "A price on a stock can be low one day and high on the next. That's just how the market works," said Barbee.

Barbee says the Department of Agriculture has worked with advocacy groups in the past but they ran into problems. "Horses were turned over to advocacy groups for $90, but they were turned back out onto open range."  That is against the law and Barbee said that's what resulted in policy shift. "It wasn't just random,” he said.

There are 31 horses up for auction next week.  Windle says they will keep raising money and save as many horses as they can.  They are also desperately trying to find the 23 horses from this auction a forever home.

Share
6 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

Ponyup - 9/23/2012 4:18 AM
1 Vote
Nevada Department of Ag should be investigating the shenanigans of this auction house---but wait a minute---they are making big bucks and the auction house is getting a bigger commission. What a bunch of crooks! There is no "market fluctuation" to justify what they did. I hope attendees will document with plenty of video all the people bidding and publish it. Maybe the advocates need to find a "good old dealer" to do the bidding for them?

Sundancer - 9/22/2012 10:34 PM
1 Vote
I hope that KRNV will have a reporter at the auction house on the 26th! would that livestock auction owner have the brass to pull that in front of the TV cameras?

Coiffure - 9/21/2012 7:15 PM
1 Vote
This is insane that you let the people of the auction bid on the horses in the first place to rid this situation from happening again. These horses need the help of the advocates and the slaughter house does not need to be bothered with these horses in the first place. as they are Americas icon, the wild mustang, GET A GRIP guys, do the right thing , these horses depend on it. They surely dont deserve to die. Change that rule , no one who has anything to do with the sale should be able to bid. get it right, arggggggg, this really makes me livid

foximer - 9/21/2012 9:26 AM
1 Vote
This has gone too far! Everything is the fault of the advocates? Give me a break. A couple of weeks ago I received a long explanation from Ag Dept's spokesperson as to why they decided to sell horses at auction. I pointed out to him that his statement was illogical and why, but he insisted he was right and that the information I gave him was wrong. He called back 10-15 minutes later and gave a totally different reason for the horses going to auction. Now they say that advocates put horses they had purchased back on the range. Wrong again. The horses in question were placed on private land, land on which the Ag. Dept. themselves turned out 50 some odd horses a few years back. To top it off, several folks that are named as suspects in the bogus animal cruelty charges against advocates are said to have been at the sale in which the horses at issue were purchased. They weren't there. The list of suspects includes just about anyone who has ever spoken out against the department in the past. Accusations and formal charges were released to the media and to private individuals days before those were named were made aware . Mr. Barbee's statement regarding price fluctuation at livestock auctions is ludicrous. At the auction in question, they offered a group of non-Virginia Range horses for bid in between two batches of Virginia Range horses. Oddly enough, those non-virginia Ranges horses went out at around $150 each, an average sale price. Only the Virginia Range horses had the bids driven to more than three times the average by a person said to be with the auction house. Sure sounds like a suspicious fluctuation to me. If you want to know what's really going on here, you need to know what questions to ask. Most reporters would not have the knowledge base to know those questions and aren't given the time to fully investigate. Thank you for covering the story. Sure hope you will be given the time needed to cover the whole story.

SuzyQ - 9/20/2012 10:21 PM
1 Vote
funny how the market price for all of the ill-fated stock horses was $50-100, it was just 3-4 times for the wild horses! this was totally an "up-yours" to the advocates! what a horrible abuse of power and what a grand show of "GOB"s.

Anne Cole - 9/20/2012 10:00 PM
1 Vote
Barbee's statement regarding the price of horses, was quite ignorant. They have been very low for some time now, a combination of high hay prices and the economy in general. It's obvious that the sale yard owner was either bidding for the kill buyer, or simply recognized that people cared so much about these horses, they were willing to pay 3-4 times over the going rate. This does not speak well of either the sale yard owner, or Barbee - he should be more involved in the protection of his states national treasurers. It's the horses that need the protection, not the kill buyers.
NEWSCASTS ON DEMAND
Anjeanette Damon Jim Rogers Jon Ralston

What's On

All content © Copyright 2013 Intermountain West Communications Company. All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
You may also view our Sitemap

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.